Questioning an Assumption in Separation of Powers

Fred Barbash has an interesting article, Why would Congress surrender , where he argues silence also passes for action. He writes that Congress has been so timid in asserting its power as a branch that it is breaking the underlying assumption of the doctrine of separation of powers.

Barbash comments that because the judicial so rarely gets involved in separation of powers arguments between the Legislative and Executive, that the two bodies basically have to negotiate it the issues out. So rather than being constitutionally explicit in solution, they tend to be political negotiations.

When one branch drops out by failing to respond, the other branch effectively sets the precedent, which is passed along to the next generation and the generation after that.

Inaction, indeed, strengthens that precedent. Over time, inaction is taken as acquiescence, a form of approval, and the precedent becomes entrenched until it's as good as law.

This is precisely what has occurred over the years. Successive decades of congressional acquiescence in the face of executive claims of war power have allowed the law to be settled exclusively by the executive branch.

Because Congress has been fearful of asserting themselves politically against the Executive it has broken a fundamental relationship and basis for separation of powers and the equilibrium it is supposed to enable between the three separate but equal branches of government:

The equilibrium of government, in the view of the Constitution's Framers, rested on a stated assumption that each branch would fight fiercely to expand its authority but just as fiercely resist encroachment from another branch.

That Congress would refuse to fight seemed unimaginable.

Interesting. The Australian Senate, which is the closest thing the Australian national government has to a separate legislative, has not been explicit in resisting executive dominance. Courtesy of Senators being in the Executive Cabinet, separation of powers is largely broken anyway. Executive discipline as government extends into the two legislative houses.

adam: I suspect: That as Bronwen Maddox has written in the Times, Democrats in Congress are actually biding their time in order to give their candidate the best shot at the Presidency.

That does also the importance of parties as an institution separate to the relative strengths of the Executive and Judicial branches, I guess.
cam: Yes, I think the biggest pressure: on constitutionalism and conscience is the party political machine.

It is interesting to see the Australian Democrats who are unique in having a party platform that is dedicated to constitutionalism (and its improvement) as well as a party constitution that places the conscience above the national executive. Labor has its pledge, and the Liberals, as a majority party, have executive and cabinet discipline which quashes the conscience. Turnball is having a few issues in this area.

Because of the structure of the Australian Democrats, and the reality that they will not be a majority party and have to worry about executive discipline in parliament, the Democrat\'s Senators all have distinct legislative personalities. Liberal and Labor Senators tend to have media personalities rather than legislative ones.

I guess majority parties are mainly marketing and PR operations. The Greens don\'t fit easily into the little description I have made. Their narrative is different again.

cam
adam: Parties: ... are one of those machines for gaming the political system, as distinct from the polity as a whole. That\'s the risk, that the political system becomes divoces from the underlying reality, or polity. I think this is what would happen in powerful feudal courts and is why concubines, eunuchs and Senators rarely make good executives.

Most Popular on South Sea Republic

The articles that have been viewed the most:

Most Popular Restaurants in Phoenix

Phoenix Eats Out is the restaurant review site for Phoenix, Scottsdale and Old Town Scottsdale which lists the modernist and contemporary restaurants, taverns and bars in the greater Phoenix area. This is the list of the most popular restaurants pages from phoenixeatsout.com that have been viewed the most; My personal favourite restaurants in Phoenix are AZ88, Postinos, Bomberos with Grazie, Humble Pie, Orange Table, The Vig, Fez and others coming close behind. View the complete list with the photo-journalistic style images on phoenixeatsout.com

Most Popular Hikes in Arizona

Arizona is an outdoor state and has lots of hiking in the city and around the state. Phoenix is unusual for most cities in having several large mountains in the center of the city with great hiking. Anyone who comes to Phoenix has to do the Echo Canyon trail on Camelback and the Summit Hike on Squaw Peak or Piesta Peak. The views of the city, suburbs and surrounding mountains are wonderful from Camelback and Piesta Peak. For more experienced hikers there is the McDowell Mountains in North Scottsdale that has several difficult and strenuous hikes in Tom's Thumb and Bell Pass. Alternatively, you can hike the highest mountain in Arizona. At 12,600 feet Humphrey's Peak is a long and difficult hike.

Alternate Australian Constitutions

Between 2004 and 2009 this site, southsearepublic.org, was a constitutional blog based on scoop which focused on Australian and global constitutional issues. One of the strongest aspects of it was the development of constitutions by those involved in the blog. These constitutions are the outcome: The constitutions were built using principles from Montesquieu's separation of powers, the enlightnment's universal political rights and the ancient Athenian technology of sortition and choice by lot.

Archives For South Sea Republic

South Sea Republic started in 2004 as an Australian constitutional blog in 2004 based on scoop software. It was an immigrative outgrowth of Kuro5hin. The archives for each year since then; The articles are ordered by views.

Who Is Cam Riley

Cam Riley I am an Australian living in the United States as a permanent resident. I am a software developer by trade and mostly work in Java and jump between middleware and front end. I originally worked in the New York area of the United States in telecommunications before moving to Washington DC and working in a mix of telecommunications, energy and ITS. I started my own software company before heading out to Arizona and working with Shutterfly. Since then I have joined a startup in the Phoenix area and am thoroughly enjoying myself.

I do a lot of photography which I post on this website, but also on flickr. I have a photo-journalistic website which lists the modernist and contemporary restaurants in phoenix. I have a site on the Australian Flying Corps [AFC] which has been around since the 1990s and which I unfortunately lost the .org URL to during a life event; however, it is under the www.australianflyingcorps.com URL now. The AFC website has gone through several iterations since the 90s and the two most recent are Australian Flying Corps Archives(2004-2002) and Australian Flying Corps Archives(2002-1999) which are good places to start.

Websites Worth Reading

Websites of friends, colleagues and of interest;